antinomy
noun·/ænˈtɪn.ə.mi/
A conflict between principles that each appear valid within their own logic, especially a contradiction between laws, duties, or rational conclusions that cannot easily be reconciled. Where paradox can be a clever twist, antinomy points to a genuine collision of norms.
The case exposed an antinomy at the heart of the law: mercy demanded one thing, precedent another.
Etymology
From Greek antinomia "conflict of laws," from anti- "against" + nomos "law." The term gained special philosophical resonance in discussions of reason's self-contradictions, but its core image remains juridical: two statutes, both binding, pulling in opposite directions.
Related Words
paradoxseeming contradiction, often resolvable by insight
dialecticthe method of working through opposing claims
aporiaan impasse of reasoning, often productive rather than merely stuck
contradictionthe plain fact; less diagnostic, less nuanced